For Reviewers
JAFT relies on expert reviewers from academia and industry. Reviewer invitations are sent by email, and you can accept or decline from the link in the email without signing in. To download the manuscript and submit your review, you sign in to a JAFT account with the email address the invitation was sent to (or create one).
Review process
- 1InvitationYou receive an email with the manuscript abstract and a review due date (typically 3 weeks). Use the button in the email to accept or decline; the invitation page shows the date to answer by.
- 2Manuscript accessAfter accepting, sign in to open the review form. You can download only the anonymised manuscript, under a neutral file name — author names, affiliations, the title page and supplementary files are withheld to preserve double-blind review. Access ends when you submit your review or when the review round closes.
- 3Submit your reviewProvide your recommendation: Accept as submitted / Minor revision / Major revision / Reject, with comments to the author (required; do not identify yourself). Confidential comments to the editor and an annotated PDF are optional. Once submitted, a review cannot be changed.
- 4RemindersIf you have not answered an invitation after a few days, or an accepted review is due soon or overdue, you may receive a reminder email. The editor handling the paper may also send you a reminder.
- 5DecisionThe Section Editor weighs the reviews and sends a recommendation; the Editor-in-Chief makes the final publication decision.
- 6Revised versionsIf the authors are asked to revise, the Section Editor may invite you to review the revised version. You then also receive the authors’ response to the reviewers, to check how each comment has been answered.
Confidentiality
All manuscripts are strictly confidential. By accepting a review invitation you agree to keep the manuscript confidential. Do not share, cite, or use any content from manuscripts under review, and do not upload them to external or public AI tools. Confidentiality extends after the editorial decision is made.
Conflicts of interest
Decline the invitation if any of the following apply:
- —Co-authorship with any of the listed authors in the past 5 years.
- —Current or recent employment at the same institution as the authors.
- —A financial interest in the outcome of the work.
- —Any other relationship that could compromise objectivity.
If in doubt, contact the editor before accepting.
Recognition
JAFT publishes an annual reviewer recognition list with each volume. All reviewers who completed at least one review during the year are acknowledged by name, with their consent.
Interested in joining the reviewer pool? Contact the editorial office with your areas of expertise.